How Accurate is a Zillow Zestimate Home Value Analysis?
Zillow.com is actually the #1 site for Home Owners to check their home’s value.
What most don’t realized is how inaccurate that Zestimate really is. Check out this chart below from Zillow.com (go to www.Zillow.com, scroll all the way down to the bottom of the page & click “Zestimate Values & Accuracy” and you’ll see this chart as well). You can also drill down by Counties for a better look at your metro Atlanta area.

Basically, Zillow’s Zestimates Home Values are not calculated by a Real Estate Market Specialist and they apparently aren’t very accurate at all. If Zillow has a 20% error rate in your area (Atlanta’s is 24% off) then that’s a potential 40% swing (20% higher & 20% lower) than what they “Zestimate” your home is worth. With that said, if we are 20% off in either direction, we wouldn’t still be in business, and our Team has been selling homes in the metro Atlanta area for 10+ years now! And as a side note: of the last 5 listings we’ve taken & sold, the Average Days on Market is ONLY 18 days and the Average List Price to Sales Price Ratio is 98%!! That’s a statistic that we’re very proud of and even get excited about!! We’re getting our sellers more money faster. That puts smiles on faces!
Based on Atlanta area market statistics, if you overprice your home (even by a little bit) it will likely take you 250+ days to sell your home & you reduce your price until you only get around 80% of your original list price. But if you price it correctly, you can sell within 30 days and even net yourself more money by pricing it properly rather than overpricing. And don’t worry so much about leaving “negotiating room” because that’s how you price yourself out of the market… the hot properties sell so close to list price that if you price it right, you won’t have to negotiate much at all. And another way to look at it: if you overprice, you’re likely not going to get an offer to negotiate anyways, so you’d be best off pricing it correctly and having a really good offer in hand in a short amount of time. The alternative can be a long, drawn out, frustrating and defeating process, without a better way of putting it.
Our job is to look at the market from a practical perspective and advise you on price based on actual comparables for your home, whether it be an Active Listing, a Pending Sale or a recently Sold home in your neighborhood or immediate area in the last 3-6 months.
It’s a simple strategy: we help you price it right, stage it, a professional photographer takes GREAT photos and from this (especially the price) you’re able to draw quick attention, and that’s what you want! A feeding frenzy! That’s when you get your BEST offer(s). You want an offer within 30 days and hopefully multiple offers, and you’re not going to get that being 20% off on pricing by using Zillow Zestimates.
So don’t trust Zillow to price your home for you… go to a Real Estate Agent you trust and you’re on your way to your selling and buying goals. Go with the pros on this one… “do what you do best and let an expert do the rest.”
And if you’re still just wanting to get a glimpse of the market before calling an agent, click here use this FREE Market Snapshot tool to view market data (including home sales), analysis & trends in your area. It will send you bi-monthly updates so you can keep up w/ the market until you’re ready to speak with a Realtor (like us!).
Hope this was helpful and thanks for reading!
The KellySellsAtlanta.com Team of Keller Williams Premier Atlanta
404-863-8680 | hometeam@kellysellsatlanta.com | www.KellySellsAtlanta.com
